Nonprofits are facing tremendous headwinds from all sides: They’re experiencing higher costs that outpace their budgets, significant fundraising challenges, and greater demands for their services.
“All of these are existential things they can’t get their head around,” explained Erika Murphy, institutional portfolio manager at Fidelity Investments.
Speaking with Institutional Investor after Fidelity released its second annual endowment and foundation survey, Murphy noted that there’s been a growing debate around spending increases. “At the same time, they’re being asked to do that with less,” she added. “And we’re seeing less coming into foundations from individual donations.” Ironically, that means there’s greater reliance on government funding.
Results from Fidelity's survey, which polled 150 U.S. nonprofits with $50 million to $500 million in assets, show that despite strong recent investment performance, funding uncertainty is rising, with 35 percent expecting a shortfall in the next 12 months.
Average spending rates are also expected to rise, increasing from 4.7 percent over the past three years to nearly 6 percent in the next 12 months. At the same time, 40 percent of respondents said the spending increases will be material over the next three years.
That pressure comes despite strong recent performance. Organizations reported average year-end returns ranging from 10 percent to 12.2 percent in each of the past three years. Even so, the share of respondents expressing high confidence fell from 34 percent in 2024 to 23 percent this year. Meanwhile, 71 percent reported only moderate confidence in their ability to achieve those targets.
Survey results also show that nearly half of respondents — 48 percent — currently work with an outsourced chief investment officer, while nearly one-third of non-users — 32 percent — are considering adopting the model within the next 12 months.
“I was surprised to see how broad the adoption of OCIO has become,” Murphy said. “I did not expect to see nearly 50 percent already using an OCIO provider.”
Another big takeaway from the survey is that only 15 percent of organizations say their portfolios are fully aligned with their mission. However, Murphy caveats that there’s nuance, with many striving to achieve their mission though grants and annual spending. “This doesn’t mean 85 percent doesn’t care, it’s just the vast majority are not willing to concede returns to better align with their mission.”
Looking deeper into the assets, Murphy noted that the portfolios are aggressively positioned, most with significant public equities positions. However, with costs rising not just in the non-profit space but across the entire economy, she was surprised there was not as much inflation hedging exposure as the larger institutions. “They don’t have a lot in the portfolios to weather a storm like from 2022 from an inflation perspective,” she said.
But Murphy does see some good news: the three-year median return for this group of allocators is 11 percent. “This cohort has much more liquidity that they could draw on should they choose to increase their spending rates,” she said.